Tony's New York Pizza II

I went here because they sell pizza by the slice. I don't know too many other pizza restaurants that sell it by the slice in the area. So the slices are premade, and then they warm them up. They're not bad but they're just not fresh. Those pizzas look like they have been sitting there a while. The place seems like a busy place. There was lots of customers coming in and out of there while we were there. The prices are definitely right here. They're very affordable. I would come back and eat here again.

I used to come by here for lunch quite a bit when I lived in this area. My wife and I were in the area for an event and stopped in. Nowadays, I make sure to do reviews on the places that I eat, and this place is as fantastic as I remember it, so a review from me is way overdue. The food is great, and the people are awesome. I highly recommend this place to anyone who wants some good New York style pizza.

Being from New York, I really appreciated the pizza. The people the atmosphere and the service was incredible. The only reason for four star on the pizza is because personally I felt like a dough was very different than New York pizza. I will give that it was crunchy underneath unlike Brothers’s pizza that’s very doughy and soft however, it wasn’t truly how New York pizzas for me. Garlic knots at the spot, they were great the cheese the sauce. Everything else is spot on. I blame it on the water that the crust didn’t taste the same. I will definitely be back.

It’s a family owned business with staff who are all friendly and welcoming each time we visit. The restaurant is a small, hole in the wall type of establishment that we have frequented at least twice a month for many years now. The pizza is hand tossed and made to order, however they do have a “buffet” which allows you to choose premade items that they reheat in the oven. Their pizzas are savory, greasy, and tasty! My 1 and only complaint is that although it is a hole in the wall, it shouldn’t mean “unkept.” This place really needs a good deep cleaning and update on appliances such as the drink machine. The walls and door entries are dusty with visible spider webs, the drink machine is faulty and water leaks when trying to dispense soda. It just needs to be replaced and fully upgraded. I really love this place however cleanliness is a non-negotiable.

Bro this was my first time so me not knowing this was going to be a massive pizza i said biggest one you got. I could barely walk Through a standard door without having to tilt the box. This place was packed with variety of races and age groups. I will be back. Today is Thursday and they have a special on Thursdays i suppose.

Super friendly staff! I ordered a slice of pizza and it was huge and really good. The garlic butter bread was soft, buttery, and smelled amazing. Definitely a nice spot if you’re craving a quick slice.

Such an underrated spot, food was immaculate and prices were insanely good!! $1.50 for a slice of cheese, and they are GENEROUS slices. Was gonna post my food but i ate it so fast all I have is an empty plate…

My wife is from the Bronx and have been searching for a place that reminded her of home. She found it here. The slices tasted great. On Thursdays you can get a cheese slice for a 1.50. The atmosphere is great and the staff is super nice. We will definitely be back.