Prince Street Pizza

Prince Street Pizza was another one of those New York spots that came highly recommended, so we had to see what all the hype was about. Located in the heart of Manhattan, this iconic pizzeria is known for its busy atmosphere, classic NYC pizza-shop feel, and some of the most popular slices in the city. We kept it simple and ordered a slice of the Veggie Pizza and a 4 Cheese Square. The veggie slice was loaded with fresh toppings and had a great balance of flavors, while the 4 Cheese Square was rich, cheesy, and incredibly satisfying. The thick Sicilian-style crust was crispy on the bottom, soft on the inside, and held up perfectly under all that melted cheese. Both slices were delicious and made for a great quick meal while exploring the city. The shop itself is small, lively, and always packed with people grabbing slices, which only adds to the authentic New York experience. While there are countless pizza spots across Manhattan, Prince Street Pizza stands out for its quality, flavor, and reputation. If you're a pizza lover visiting NYC, it's definitely a place worth adding to your list.

An amazing pizza place that sells the best pizza I've had in New York so far! They offer both squared pizza slices as well as the original triangle slice, but I think their specialty is the square ones since these are the ones that looked best on the counter, as well as almost all of the other clients around us had them. We wanted to try as many topping combinations as possible, so we started off with 1 square of each - spicy spring (with pepperoni, fresh mozzarella & pecorino romano cheese), four cheese (with fresh mozzarella, shredded mozzarella, ricotta & pecorino romano) & spicy vodka (spicy vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella & pecorino romano). All were great but my favorite by far was the spicy spring, that we topped with hot honey served on the side. The sweet & spicy honey topping on top of the meaty and crunchy pepperoni created an irresistible combination that's tough to beat. After having these 3 slices, we had to order some more - this time we ordered a slice of the meat lovers pizza (with pepperoni, oven roasted sausage, pepperoni bacon bits, fresh mozzarella & green jalapeno). This one was also really good, but still didn't beat the spicy spring that was just had to have another slice of, with a hot honey drizzle of course. If you're in the Soho area, make sure to definitely not miss out on this amazing pizzeria!!

Not only did they send us the wrong pizza, the wrong order, hung up on us multiple times, but they were also incredibly rude to us. We ordered a pepperoni pizza and two slices of cake, and then they sent us a veggie pizza instead. Accidents happen, no big deal. The bad part is how they dealt with it and the pizza they did send. First off, the pizza they sent was raw. I picked up a slice and all the topping fell also. Also, the cheese was sliding off and it was like the pizza had been flipped over. The cherry on top, there was tinfoil in the crust. TIN FOIL IN THE CRUST. Next, we called them. 3 times. The first two they picked up, told us “hold on hold on” as soon as they picked up, and then hung up the phone on us. Then, when we finally got through, they put us “on hold” and it was clear they just put the phone down by the voices we were able to hear in the background. He finally picked up the phone, refused to refund us, and said “well if you don’t want a new pizza I’m just hanging up, this ain’t worth my time”. This place suck. Dont order. Will never order again.

This was probably hands-down the best pizza I ever had in my life. The naughty pizza is so good. Me and my partner had to get another slice. It’s definitely a walk-in ,order and get out. It’s a bit small but the line moves fast. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is great. And then we also came back right before we left to the airport. Definitely have to check this out if you’re coming to New York to visit.

Recently went on a pizza quest and both my kids and I rated Prince Street Pizza the highest. It’s an oldie but goodie and always consistent. Chicago location isn’t good but the NY one is the best. The sauce has a slight sweetness and the slice is thin crunchy and foldable.

Easily the best pizza I've ever had. We got the spicy vodka, cheese slice, margarita and 4 cheese. Regular cheese slice was the best of them all. Worth all the hype.

Pizza was great. I got the vodka sauce and the margarita overall taste flavor was spot on the vodka slice came out hot and fresh. The margarita pizza was sitting out. They didn’t reheat nor asked to heat it up, so it was cold not a fan of that. The restaurant has a slice pick up and also a place to order pizza depending what you want. Good vibe cool experience bring cash to save a couple bucks.

The pepperoni square pizza was as delicious as it looks, the service was ok but the gentleman that spoke to me was hard to understand. No bathrooms here for customers and you will most likely stand if you're eating inside which is a very small crowded area. I love those white & green checkered pizza boxes and the vibe in and around the Prince Street area. I would definitely go back! With a bathroom and a place to sit I would have gave 5 stars!