East Village Pizza

One of my favorite pizza spots in NYC. The slices are huge, fresh, and packed with flavor. We tried several different varieties and every one was delicious. There’s plenty of seating inside, and they also have outdoor seating. With the beautiful NYC weather lately, sitting outside with a hot slice and people-watching in the East Village is hard to beat. Friendly staff, quick service, and great pizza. Definitely worth a stop if you’re in the neighborhood. 🍕☀️

My husband and I stopped by yesterday and absolutely loved it. We tried the Margherita, Pepperoni, Plain Cheese, Baked Ziti, and Pepperoni Jalapeño slices, plus the garlic knots. Everything was fresh and really tasty. Our favorite was the Pepperoni Jalapeño slice — so flavorful with just the right kick. The garlic knots were also delicious. The staff was very welcoming and made us feel right at home. Such a great pizza spot in the East Village, and we’ll definitely be coming back! 🍕😊

This is the spot for a true New York slice. East Village Pizza has been serving the neighborhood and it never disappoints. The slices are huge – foldable New York-style with a thin, crispy crust. Two slices and you're done. I always go for the Margherita – simple, fresh, and perfectly cheesy. They also have creative options like pepperoni jalapeño with hot honey if you want to switch it up.

As someone with a demanding lifestyle in finance, finding a reliable, no-nonsense spot that serves pure comfort food in the dead of night is an absolute necessity. East Village Pizza has been holding down the neighborhood since 1997, and it completely lives up to its legendary status. The owner’s story of going from the original delivery guy to owning an internationally famous shop is pure classic NYC street culture. At around $4.99 a slice, the value proposition here is unbeatable—especially in Manhattan. The slices are massive (one easily equals two normal ones), and they stay open until 3 AM (and up to 5 AM on weekends), making it the ultimate high-energy refueling station after a grueling shift or a long night out. 👍👍The Beef Pepperoni: A total game-changer. Unlike standard pork pepperoni, they use an all-beef version that delivers an incredibly robust, savory oil profile. It has an excellent chew and a depth of flavor that sets it miles apart from generic slices. 👍Double Stacked: Pure carb heaven. If you've just put in a 14-hour workday and need to turn your brain off, this cheese-heavy, double-layered masterpiece is the ultimate stress reliever. 👍Buffalo Chicken: Hits you with that perfect tangy, spicy kick, balanced beautifully by a rich blend of melted cheese. 👍Margherita: Crisp, thin crust with an incredibly balanced tomato acidity and fresh mozzarella base. Simple execution done flawlessly. It’s an old-school neighborhood gem with zero pretension and maximum flavor. If you want an authentic taste of Manhattan's finest street food, skip the trendy tourist traps and come straight here.

I visited East Village Pizza recently and had a fantastic experience. It’s impressive to see a pizzeria that has been serving New Yorkers for so many years while maintaining such great quality. During my visit, I tried the Margherita Slice, Pepperoni Slice, Plain Cheese Slice, Baked Ziti Slice, and Pepperoni Jalapeño Slice, and each one had its own unique flavor. I also got to try their famous double-stacked pizza, which definitely lived up to the hype. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and made with care. It’s easy to understand why this place has remained a local favorite for so long. I highly recommend East Village Pizza to anyone looking for authentic New Yorkstyle pizza.

One of the best pizza spots in Manhattan, NYC, serving incredible New York-style pizza since 1997! We tried the Veggie Pizza, Eggplant Pizza, Margherita Pizza, and the famous Baked Ziti Pizza, and every slice was absolutely delicious. The crust was perfectly crispy and foldable, the toppings were fresh, and the portions were huge. The Baked Ziti Pizza was especially memorable—rich, cheesy, and unlike anything else we've tried. Every slice showcased authentic New York flavor and quality. What truly stands out is the owner's passion for pizza, which is visible in every detail. From the recipes to the fresh ingredients and consistent quality, it's clear this place takes pride in what they serve. If you're looking for some of the best pizza in Manhattan, East Village Pizza is a must-visit. A true NYC institution that has been delighting pizza lovers since 1997!

Hands down one of the best pizza spots in NYC! The slices are always fresh, crispy, cheesy, and packed with so much flavor. I love the classic New York pizza vibe and the friendly atmosphere here. Such a must-visit spot in the East Village, especially when you’re craving a good NYC slice. Definitely coming back for more!

Had the best experience with East Village Pizza - we got 4 pies to go and they were AMAZING. Perfect for a group dinner! Stayed hot, not greasy, thin crust and the different menu options are fabulous. Highly recommend, and the staff are so kind as well!!