Island House Bar and Grill

Lilly took great care of us! We sat on the nice patio after a perfect beach day. The wings are humongous, crispy and saucey. The pulled pork was great and the fries are perfectly seasoned. Bonus that the IU flag was waving!! Thank you so much for a great meal!

They literally had NO FISH. What? And to top it off $16 for wine at a local (dive) bar is just unacceptable. Music was good. Good vibe. Come to drink beer and eat bar food. That is all.

I walked in tonight 05/24/2026 at 8:45pm, I was told that it wasn't possible to serve any food so I just ordered beers BUT while sitting g at the counter I saw a group of four people in the other room being served a lot of food so I politely reasked the waitress, a young with long dark hair, if I could have something but she promptly replied that the group had ordered earlier. How early I wondered? AGAIN, a couple with two teen sons who were enjoying beers at the time that we accessed the bar, were served a giant dinner at 09:30pm. At that point I didn't even want to reask. The waitress is a liar and a rude one, not even offering to help with something like "M'am, may I get you something very simple because our kitchen is closing early?" Zero tip is the least she deserves and, for sure, not being a tourist and living in the area, I will point for worse the place for anybody from now on and signal to the hospitality management groups.

We were here on Sunday. Our bartender Annalise, did her best to keep everyone happy and taken care of even though the whole restaurant and bar was full. She did amazing for being the only bartender. The “manager” was in pjs and flip flops while behind the bar. Between the way she was dressed and her major attitude she is not a good look as a “manager” We will be back to see Annalise when it is not as crowded and short staffed.

You know this place is really went downhill in the last 6 months. We just visited this place again the other day ordered wings which we used to love they were not cooked all the way with this weird texture. Also none of my wings looks like wings they looks more like a knuckle.. send out they're usually tasty freeze weren't even cooked all the way we're still white and gummy in the middle. There was literally one staff member that you could tell was a professional although she hasn't been there long. The rest of them were rude didn't know how to smile and unattentive.

Another amazing experience at a local gem. Appears divey but has great live music, outdoor seating, fun events, and most importantly the best fish topped salads I have ever had. Their chef really knows how to cook mahi right! Other good things on the menu too; fun for a night out or lunch after the beach.

The food was okay. Not bad, but not remarkable. We had a burger and a fried chicken sandwich. Nothing to get excited about, it could have been better, especially for the prices they charge. The atmosphere is neat and the service is friendly.

Unfortunately I’m having to update my original 5 Star Review from May 2021 to a 1 Star. Apparently it’s under new ownership, the menu is limited and the pizza is nowhere near as good it once was. The pizza with ham and pineapple is the current offering. The other picture were what is was before. Disappointed. Original Review Casual island vibe with nice indoor and outdoor dinning. Pizza had great flavor, plenty of cheese with a nicely toasted crust. Usually have live music on Saturday night on the patio. Great spot to grab a bite and a cold beer after a day on the beach.