New York Bakery Café

Delicious and beautifully decorated cakes. I’ve gotten a few slices so far. They all have been super yummy but my favorites are the tiramisu and berry cheesecake. Their cheesecake is especially creamy. I’m already looking forward to my next visit!

Coffee and tea were so good. Got a gingerbread latte and a chamomile tea as well as lemon meringue and chocolate. Loved it here and would 11/10 recommend.

I wish I got make pictures because wow! Amazing shop, great staff and friendly ambiance. It felt very much like community, and it felt like most people knew each other there. The almond cookie was unbelievably fresh and soft, the baklava is soaked in juicy flavors and the leek pie was crispy and stuffed. Prices are extremely reasonable.

This is literally the first time I’ve ever been moved to write a review, but unfortunately the experience warranted it. I ordered a handful of different items and really wanted to enjoy them, but they all either tasted rotten or like some sort of musty cleaning product? It’s almost like the glass case flavored them somehow? I’m concerned there is mold in the case. We ordered 6 desserts and quite literally all of them tasted this way, except for the creme brûlée which tasted of spoiled milk. I didn’t even order creme brûlée, I ordered flan, but was given the creme brûlée by mistake. I’m an industry worker myself and never write reviews like this because I generally hate receiving them as an employee, but this was really unfortunate. My partner and I actually couldn’t swallow a single item we purchased. I spent about 20 dollars on these couple sweets and was really looking forward to them, but now I don’t think I’ll ever return considering I don’t know if any of this is edible or even currently food-safe. As you can see in the photo, we only took one bite of everything. I’m sorry if this sounds harsh but it was pretty rough guys.

It was our first time visiting, and the staff gave us such a warm and friendly welcome. A special thank you to Jeta and Kirian for their outstanding kindness and hospitality. The cakes and pies were absolutely delicious, and the cupcakes were so beautiful that I couldn’t resist buying some for my kids. I highly recommend this place!

The Bakery is beautiful and the workers are very kind. I came in for a birthday cake and they asked themselves if I wanted happy birthday with my name written on it and the lady who wrote on it even put hearts on the bottom!! It came out very pretty and I loved it

If you’re looking for a spot in NYC that truly delivers on both quality and variety, New York Bakery Cafe is an absolute standout. From the moment you walk in, you’re hit with that warm, irresistible aroma of freshly baked goods that instantly sets the tone. The display cases are packed with an eye-catching selection of cakes, pastries, cookies, and more—everything looks vibrant, beautifully crafted, and honestly hard to choose from. What really makes this bakery special is the freshness and flavor. Everything is baked on-site, and you can genuinely taste the quality in every bite. Customers consistently rave about how rich yet balanced the desserts are—whether it’s a light and fluffy chocolate mousse cake or a creamy cheesecake that practically melts in your mouth.  Beyond sweets, they also offer savory options like spinach and cheese pie, which adds a nice touch if you’re craving something a little less sugary. Pair your treat with a coffee (they’ve got a solid selection), and you’ve got the perfect little NYC indulgence. The atmosphere is clean, cozy, and welcoming, making it a great place to stop by whether you’re grabbing something quick or lingering a bit to enjoy your dessert. Plus, the staff is known for being friendly and helpful, which always makes the experience even better.  Overall, New York Bakery Cafe is one of those places that feels like a hidden gem—reliable, delicious, and totally worth going out of your way for. If you love baked goods, this is the kind of spot you’ll keep coming back to.

We had the best time celebrating my birthday with delicious cake and pie! Jeta is so sweet! We truly felt her genuine kindness and heart to make people happy! Thank you for the wonderful experience Jeta and Kirian! ☺️