Goodfella's

This place has quickly become one of my favorite spots on Staten Island. The atmosphere is great with a really clean modern bar, TVs for the games, and a lively dining room that makes it perfect whether you’re going out with friends or just grabbing dinner. The pizza here is phenomenal. The crust has that perfect crisp with a soft center and the ingredients taste really fresh. Every time I come here I end up ordering pizza because it is just that good. It is easily some of the best pizza on Staten Island. What surprised me the most though is how strong the rest of the menu is. The appetizers are excellent. The fried calamari was fresh and perfectly cooked and the mozzarella sticks were loaded with flavor. You can tell the kitchen really cares about the food they put out. They also serve great steaks which makes the place even better if you are going with people who want something different than pizza. The menu has a really nice balance between classic Italian dishes, appetizers, pizza, and steak options. The service has always been friendly and the vibe inside makes you want to stay for a while, especially if you are sitting near the bar watching a game. Highly recommend this spot if you are on Staten Island. It has amazing pizza, great appetizers, and solid steaks all in one place. Definitely worth checking out.

All I can say is wow. I ordered a large vodka pie and it was amazing. Now I can taste why this pizza is award winning. And that’s not even the best part. The chicken roll was phenomenal. Every bite better than the last. Very good food. Very filling. Absolutely recommend Goodfellas for unparalleled taste.

Goodfellas Pizza School is the real deal. The 4-day class wasn’t just a course — it was a full experience. From dough fundamentals to technique, workflow, and the why behind every step, I learned so much more than I expected. The instructors are incredibly knowledgeable, professional, and genuinely invested in their students’ success. And the restaurant itself is outstanding. I ate nearly everything on the menu, and every single item was excellent. The variety is impressive, the quality is top-notch, and it’s clear the food is being made by true professionals who care deeply about their craft. I’m beyond excited to take what I learned and start implementing it. If you’re serious about pizza and want to level up, this experience is absolutely worth it.

Always a great experience coming to Goodfellas, delicious food, great staff. Just amazing. I came here with my partner on New Year’s Eve and got a gluten free pesto shrimp pizza, he got the duck fat infused pork chop… chefs kiss ☺️ Our waitress Sheila B was a gem. Happy and blessed new year everyone ❤️

The appetizers were great got the stuffed mushrooms and baked clams, baked clams were a little on the saltier side. Lobster bisque was wonderful too. Pizza was the star of the show, got the vodka and smoking goodfella halves and it was extremely good. The service was wonderful, Kaitlyn was great and very helpful and the Owner Scott was an awesome guy, came to talk and check on us.

hands down the best Italian food I've ever had, pizza was beyond incredible! The owner Scott was fantastic and so were his staff.

I grabbed a quick bite here after hearing it was a popular spot for late-night cravings. The pizza was decent with a nice crust, but it felt like they were in such a hurry to get orders out that some of the toppings were unevenly spread. It definitely hits the spot if you are looking for something fast and filling during a long night out, but don't expect a gourmet experience. It is a solid no-frills place that gets the job done when you need a simple meal.

I really enjoyed the casual vibe here and the staff made me feel right at home as soon as I walked through the door. The slice I ordered was cooked just right with a nice crispy crust and plenty of cheese, which is exactly what I was hoping for. It’s a great spot to grab a simple, satisfying meal without breaking the bank, and I appreciate how consistent they are. I’ll definitely be coming back whenever I’m in the neighborhood and need a quick, tasty fix.