Dorlan's Tavern & Oyster Bar

We went today and the food was superb and the lovely waitress kaithleen was super helpful, polite and on top of her game . It was a pleasure to eat in there .

Best fish sandwich I have ever had in my life. Service was fast and exceptional. Also ordered the fried chicken wrap. Very good. Will 100% be back.

Dorlan's, located in the historic South Street Seaport in New York City, is a fantastic spot that perfectly balances a classic pub atmosphere with high-quality food and drinks. I recently went there and was thoroughly impressed, especially by their take on comfort food classics. My friends and I were craving something hearty, and we were not disappointed. We ordered a big chicken sandwich and a juicy burger to share, and both were outstanding. The chicken sandwich was a true showstopper—perfectly fried to a golden crisp while remaining incredibly moist and tender on the inside. It was a generous size and had a fantastic, flavorful crunch with every bite. The burger was equally impressive. It was cooked to a perfect medium, with a patty so juicy and rich that it practically melted in your mouth. The classic toppings and a toasted bun made for a flawless burger experience. What made the meal even better were the sides and drinks. The fries were a perfect companion, hot and crispy, and just the right amount of salt. And the cocktails were excellent. We each had a few different ones, and they were all expertly mixed and well-balanced—they weren't just an afterthought but a highlight of the meal. The entire place has a warm and inviting vibe, and the staff was friendly and attentive. For a spot that feels like a cozy neighborhood tavern but serves up incredible, elevated pub fare and great drinks, Dorlan's is a definite winner.

I’ve been here a few times with the family, and the food has been excellent during previous visits, which is why we chose to return recently. Most of the dishes were great, but unfortunately, the hamburger sliders were severely undercooked. One of the servers (not the one attending to us) took the sliders back with the intention of correcting the raw patties, only to return with them still undercooked. It appeared they put our half-chewed sliders back into the oven or a plate to try to cook them, but they were still raw. We had to tell the server that we did not want the raw ground beef patties. Our actual server was friendly and took the sliders off our bill. We will be returning, but likely will not be trying the sliders again.

Awesome local spot of the beaten path. Their Dorlan's pilsner was refreshing, staff was great good was descent and quickly served. Had 4 beers buffalo shrimp, fish and chips, sliders and quesadillas to go.... Totaling 130$

Our bar tender was super nice and nothing wrong with the beer or anything we got. Problem was when I got the bill the club soda was 5 bucks. They didn’t even warn us which I don’t think was right. Otherwise great place and the staff was great especially our bartender.

I came with low expectations on a Sun eve, and walked away impressed. Solid 4.2 here. They started me off on the flavored house popcorn, within the first 2 minutes, which set the pace for my speedy (roadrunner) experience. The mango avocado salad appeared in like 60 seconds after ordered, was mostly arugula with a smattering of mango and tomatoes - Dorlans must have felt the recent tariff hit on the avos so really hard to track down, or maybe just didn't have time - good healthy taste overall. The fish n chips was very good, good beer batter and fresh fish. Now if I could only replace those skinny fries with British fat fries... Overall, recommended. I'll be back to sample more of that menu.

By far, the BEST watermelon margarita I have tasted has been at this spot! Delicious!!🍉🍹👌🏼 Their buffalo chicken wrap and fries were very good too. The service was excellent. Recommend to try.